Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Middle Cosmos's avatar

"Science does not progress unless researchers look for new ways of knowing." Leonelli's framing points to something Nagarjuna was working out in the 2nd century: that even the method of knowing can't be fixed in place.

The Buddhist term is pratityasamutpada. Dependent origination. Knowledge arises in relation to conditions. Change the conditions, and the knowledge has to change with them. That is what vulnerability means here: refusing to treat the current position as the final one.

The phrase that landed for me is "need for closure." Kruglanski and Webster call it the enemy of open science. In Zen, the same pattern has a different name: attachment to views. Whether the framing is the same thing or just a structural rhyme, I'm genuinely unsure. But the shape of the problem is hard to ignore.

Andrés Delgado-Ron MD MSc's avatar

I smell a can of worms opening up. A very old can https://mako.cc/writing/coleman-hill-how_free_became_open.pdf

1 more comment...

Ready for more?